Carbon Contracts for Difference
Climate protection contracts

Project lawyer for Carbon Contracts for Difference

As a lawyer specialising in energy law with experience in environmental and funding law, David Engel supports your funding project in all project phases, from the preparatory procedure through the bid to implementation.

Eight years of experience in energy law, in law firms and in the legal department of an industrial company.

Working together

The energy lawyer in the project

Legal questions arise throughout the procedure: in structuring the project, in the bid, in negotiations with project partners and in implementation.

Once engaged, David Engel works as part of the project team, alongside the business unit or in support of the legal department. Where the project is known from the start, the project contracts are drafted and negotiated without any need to get up to speed again. The same applies to the classification under energy, environmental and commercial law in the implementation phase.

Added to this is hands-on project experience in structuring hydrogen and CCS projects under energy and permitting law, in drafting and negotiating project contracts and PPAs, and in supporting EPC contracts. In the 2026 bidding procedure, he provided legal support for projects. About the firm

Project contracts

Drafting, review and negotiation of the contracts with project partners: hydrogen supply, CO2 transport and storage, power supply and PPA, and supply contracts. Support with EPC contracts.

Obligations and deadlines schedule

Deadlines and obligations under energy and environmental law, the funding guideline, the grant decision and the Carbon Contract for Difference in one overview, updated across the phases.

Regulatory classification and risk assessment

Individual legal questions arising from the funding guideline, emissions trading, energy and permitting law, or a risk assessment in the form of an expert opinion.

Cost-efficient handling

Flexible billing models: from a fixed fee for work packages through on-call billing by the hour to a monthly block of hours at a reduced project hourly rate.

Efficient handling with AI: AI brings a decisive efficiency advantage in document review, research and contract analysis. The efficiency gain increases if the project is supported from the start. The time saved is passed on in the price. More: Energy and commercial law with AI

Enquiries to mail@engel-legal.de or +49 931 73041732.

Phase model

A Carbon Contract for Difference in six phases

On the left are the company's steps, on the right the legal topics in each phase. The legal obligations and deadlines schedule is drawn up at the start and updated with each phase.

As of 15 November 2026. The call for funding for the 2027 bidding procedure has not yet been published.

Project · Steps
ENGEL | LEGALLegal support
01

Project and preparatory procedure

  • Scope of the project: reference systemThe conventional production process against which the project is compared. The granting authority specifies it in the call for funding. It applies for the entire term., system boundary and energy carriers
  • Allocation to the funding volume: CCU/CCS, hydrogen or process heat
  • Decision on an individual application or a consortium
  • Letters of intent with project partners for hydrogen, CO2 transport and storage, and electricity
  • Preparatory procedure: application to participate, project description and quantitative questionnaire by 14 December 2026, and for participants in the 2026 bidding procedure the confirmation declaration
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Eligibility of the project: access thresholds, permissible energy carriers and grounds for exclusion
  • Contract structure of the projectAllocation of services, risks and remuneration between the company, suppliers, service providers, and infrastructure and plant operators.: own operation or operator model, consequences for the plant operator and eligibility to apply
  • Consortium: requirements, joint and several liability and consortium agreement
  • Non-disclosure agreements, letters of intent and term sheets with project partners

Obligations and deadlines schedule drawn up

02

Bid

  • Determination of the additional costs and the base contract priceThe additional costs of the project per tonne of CO2 equivalent avoided, as estimated in the bid. It is the basis for the annual grant or surplus payment.
  • Financing plan and securityA bank guarantee or bank surety that must be evidenced with the application. It secures the Federal Government's claims to the compensation payment and contractual penalty.
  • Site and employment concept
  • Preliminary agreements on hydrogen supply, CO2 transport and storage, power supply and grid connection
  • Bid decision: internal approval of the binding bid
  • Submission of application and bid, expected from May 2027, and binding effect of the bid
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Preliminary agreements: conditions, rights of withdrawal, security and terms, aligned with the bid validity period, award and operational start
  • Obligations until the award: no early start of the projectThe first firm commitment for the project, for example an order or the start of construction. Land acquisition and permits do not count. A start of the project before the grant decision generally rules out funding., declarations and evidence from project partners for the application
  • Cumulation with and offsetting of other funding
  • Risk assessment for the bid decision: compensation paymentAnyone who terminates the Carbon Contract for Difference after the award and before the operational start owes the Federal Government a compensation payment. In the 2026 bidding procedure, it amounted to 1 percent of the maximum funding amount. The amount for 2027 is set by the call for funding. if the project is abandoned after the award, contractual penalties and recovery

Obligations and deadlines schedule updated: application deadline, application documents and bid validity period

03

Award and Carbon Contract for Difference

  • Award and grant decision
  • Conclusion of the Carbon Contract for DifferenceA private-law contract with the Federal Government alongside the grant decision. It comes into existence with the award and also governs the surplus payments.
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Review of the grant decision and its ancillary provisions
  • Obligations under the Carbon Contract for Difference until the operational start

Obligations and deadlines schedule updated: ancillary provisions of the decision and deadlines under the Carbon Contract for Difference

04

Permitting, project contracts and investment decision

  • Permit for the plant and, for CCS projects, approval of the CO2 pipeline
  • Completion of FEED (Front-End Engineering and Design)
  • Award of the EPC contract and conclusion of the supply contracts
  • Hydrogen supply, CO2 transport and storage, and power supply secured
  • Final investment decision (FID)
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Review of individual legal questions in the permitting procedure, for example the classification of CO2, hydrogen and electricity lines on the plant premises
  • Alignment of the project contracts with the funding conditions: operational start, reduction obligations and use of energy carriers
  • Support with EPC and supply contracts: completion dates, performance guarantees and liability
  • Hydrogen supply agreement, CO2 transport and storage agreements, electricity supply agreement and PPA
  • Grid connection and metering concept: extension of the connection, third-party installations on the site
  • Legal preparation of the investment decision: legal summary in the decision paper and, for debt financing, direct agreementsDirect agreements between the project company, its contract partners and the financing banks, for example with step-in rights for the bank in EPC and supply contracts.

Obligations and deadlines schedule updated: conditions and ancillary provisions of the permit

05

Construction and operational start

  • Construction and commissioning of the plant
  • Operational startStart of the 15-year contract term. Trial operation does not count. The deadline for the operational start is set by the call for funding. within the deadline set in the call for funding
  • Monitoring concept at the operational start
  • Return of the security
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Delays: postponement of the operational start in the event of delayed infrastructure or force majeure
  • Termination before the operational start: compensation payment and exclusion from the following bidding procedures
  • Claims against the EPC contractor and suppliers for delay and defects

Obligations and deadlines schedule updated: deadline for the operational start and conditions

06

Operation over 15 years

  • Annual report on emissions and energy carriers by 30 April of the following year
  • Annual settlement: payment of the grant or surplus paymentIf the effective CO2 price is above the contract price, the company pays the difference to the Federal Government. The annual payment is capped. to the Federal Government
  • Compliance with the reduction obligationsUnder the funding guideline, a reduction of at least 50 percent compared with the reference system from the fourth full calendar year and 85 percent in the last twelve months of the term.
  • Changes to the project and to the use of energy carriers
ENGEL | LEGAL
  • Changes requiring consent: use of energy carriers, site, transfer of the plant to third parties
  • Legal consequences of falling short of the reduction obligations: reduction of the grant, contractual penalty, revocation and recovery
  • Surplus payment: cap and application for early termination of the payment obligations
  • Legal support on monitoring and the annual report, aligned with the monitoring plan and emissions report under emissions trading
  • Ongoing energy-law advice on relief: network charges, the special equalisation scheme (Besondere Ausgleichsregelung), electricity price compensation
  • Disruptions, defects and claims against contract partners

Obligations and deadlines schedule updated: ongoing reporting and evidence duties

Predictable costs: fixed fee for clearly defined assignments, otherwise a cost estimate upfront.

Learn more →